Palestine Action arrests outside Supreme Court

I wrote to the Metropolitan Police Commission last week saying:

Dear Commissioner

As you will know, yesterday (3rd November), around twenty-five campaigners were arrested outside the Supreme Court for holding up signs using the same or similar words said by Sarah Helm, the wife of the government’s National Security Adviser, who had posted on X “God help us authors who support Palestine and Palestine Action.” Her words were widely reported in the media with the police stating it “does not meet criminal threshold.” This seems common sense advice and I commend the police for taking no action. However, it is very confusing for members of the public when they are subsequently arrested for holding up signs using similar language, such as “God help us normal people who support Palestine and Palestine Action.”

I am concerned about reputational damage being suffered by the Met Police as a result of the arrests of those supporting Palestine Action.

There appears to be a lack of clarity about what is and isn’t support for this proscribed organisation.

I did oppose the proscription of Palestine Action with an unsuccessful Fatal Motion in the Lords and worry it is damaging both the public’s support for anti-terrorism laws and the police’s enforcement of them. The proscription of PA has led to over four thousand people being arrested for completely non-violent protests, such as sitting silently while holding up a placard. It has diverted police resources, clogged up the courts and could result in further over-crowding of prisons. Given the nature of the crimes committed by those on early release, as a result of over-crowding, it does feel like the police and the Govt have got all their priorities wrong.

It has also resulted in a great deal of confusion about what does and doesn’t constitute terrorism.

After twelve years on the Metropolitan Police Authority, I felt I had a good understanding of the serious nature of dealing with terrorist threats, but the proscription of Palestine Action has overextended the definition and a large section of public opinion does not agree with it. There are examples of the police ignoring a protest in one part of the country, but making arrests for exactly the same form of protest in another area. A form of words on a placard my get a person arrested on one day, but fail to get a reaction from the police on another.

The police clearly have a large degree of operational discretion in how they apply the rules on the proscription of Palestine Action and I therefore urge you to focus the Met’s scarce resources on the public’s priority of dealing with violent and serious crimes.

Yours jj

Crime and Policing Bill Report Stage Day 6

As the Green Peers are not part of the usual channels, we were not able to give our views on the fact that this very important piece of legislation is being bullied through this House by the Government. It is absolutely outrageous that we do not have another day for Report. I hold both Members of the Front Bench accountable for this. It is not acceptable. This is no way to make good law, when we are going to be very tired in the later hours and possibly in the early hours. Continue reading “Crime and Policing Bill Report Stage Day 6” →

Crime and Policing Bill Committee Stage Day 15

Regulators such as Ofwat have been in bed with the water industry bosses, and the Environment Agency has lost staff and legitimacy. Labour are wedded to private ownership of water and refuse to consider public ownership, even though it would be the most popular legislation they could enact this Parliament.

These amendments take a direct route to stopping pollution by making this personal to the people at the top. If they do not spend the money to invest and reduce pollution, then that is a crime. They are taking the public’s money and failing to improve. Continue reading “Crime and Policing Bill Committee Stage Day 15” →

Crime and Policing Bill Committee Stage Day 12

Police officers do a very difficult job—I am very appreciative of that and understand the problems—and most do it well. But when someone abuses that role, the damage is much greater for public trust. It is wider than any single case. Trust in policing depends on people believing that no one is above the law. At the moment the rule of law is not for us all, as exemplified by the way we treat police in some cases. Continue reading “Crime and Policing Bill Committee Stage Day 12” →

Crime and Policing Bill Committee Stage Day 11

His Majesty’s Inspectorate of Constabulary and Fire & Rescue Services does really important work in shining a light on what is going wrong, but inspection takes us only so far. My amendment asks whether the follow-through is strong enough and whether lessons from other regulated sectors could help turn findings into lasting improvements. In healthcare, education and financial services, regulators are able to require change. Those systems exist because inspection without action does not protect the public. The amendment invites us to consider whether policing oversight could benefit from similar clarity and grip. Continue reading “Crime and Policing Bill Committee Stage Day 11” →

Crime and Policing Bill Committee Stage Day 10

At some point we have to accept that the police’s use of Facial Recognition Software needs regulation. We cannot accept that the police constantly mark their own homework. We were reassured that all the flaws in the algorithm and so on had been fixed, but clearly we cannot be sure of that because we do not have any way of knowing exactly what the flaws were and who has fixed them. Live facial recognition represents a huge departure from long-established principles of British policing. In this country, people are not required to identify themselves to the police unless they are suspected of wrongdoing. Live facial recognition turns that principle on its head by subjecting everyone in range of a camera to an automated identity check. It treats innocent members of the public as potential suspects and undermines the presumption of innocence. Continue reading “Crime and Policing Bill Committee Stage Day 10” →

Crime and Policing Bill Commitee Stage Day 9

Continue reading “Crime and Policing Bill Commitee Stage Day 9” →

My debate on Facial Recognition Technology: Safeguards

I tabled a Topical Oral Question in response to reports last week of built in bias in the FR software resulting in women and individuals from ethnic minorities being much more likely to be misrecognised by it: because the software is much better at recognising white men they are less likely to be misidentified and negatively affected by it. The Financial Times reported on it here Continue reading “My debate on Facial Recognition Technology: Safeguards” →